Homemade chesapeake-style (old bay copycat) seasoning in a rustic ceramic bowl and glass jar, surrounded by its whole spices and ingredients on a wooden table

Seasoning blend

Chesapeake-Style (Old Bay Copycat) Seasoning Recipe

This is our homemade Chesapeake-style seafood seasoning, a copycat of the flavour of Old Bay® built on celery salt, paprika, mustard, pepper and warm spices. It is not the branded product; mix the recipe below in 5 minutes for about ¼ cup.

Quick facts

  • **Region:** American Mid-Atlantic
  • **Heat:** 2/5
  • **Flavour:** Celery-salty and savoury with warm baking-spice notes (bay, nutmeg, cinnamon) and gentle heat.
  • **Makes:** about 4 tbsp (about ¼ cup, ~48 g)
  • **Time:** 5 minutes

Homemade Chesapeake-Style (Old Bay Copycat) Seasoning recipe

about 4 tbsp (about ¼ cup, ~48 g) · **Prep:** 5 min · **Shelf life:** 6 months airtight, cool and dark

IngredientAmountGrams
Celery salt2 tbsp33.0 g
Paprika2 tsp4.6 g
Mustard powder1 tsp2.6 g
Black pepper1 tsp2.3 g
Ground bay leaf1 tsp0.6 g
Ground ginger½ tsp0.9 g
Nutmeg¼ tsp0.6 g
Cinnamon¼ tsp0.7 g
Allspice¼ tsp0.5 g
Ground cloves⅛ tsp0.3 g
Cayenne½ tsp0.9 g
White pepper¼ tsp0.6 g
  1. Step 1: Step 1: Measure

    Measure all 12 ingredients into a small bowl; crumble dried herbs between your fingers.

    Step 1: measuring the ingredients for homemade chesapeake-style (old bay copycat) seasoning into small bowls and measuring spoons
    Illustration
  2. Step 2: Step 2: Mix

    Whisk for 30 seconds until the colour is even with no streaks.

    Step 2: whisking homemade chesapeake-style (old bay copycat) seasoning in a glass bowl until the colour is even
    Illustration
  3. Step 3: Step 3: Store

    Funnel into a clean, dry glass jar, seal and label with the date.

    Step 3: homemade chesapeake-style (old bay copycat) seasoning funnelled into a sealed glass spice jar, ready to store
    Illustration

Storage

Keep in an airtight glass jar away from the stove, light and moisture. Ground spices lose aroma after about 6 months; if it no longer smells strongly when rubbed between your fingers, make a fresh batch. Do not shake the jar over a steaming pan; moisture causes clumping.

Heat and flavour profile

Heat 2/5. Celery-salty and savoury with warm baking-spice notes (bay, nutmeg, cinnamon) and gentle heat.

How to use chesapeake-style on seafood

  • Blue crabs: Layer generously while steaming over beer and vinegar.
  • Steamed shrimp: 2 tsp per 450 g, toss right after steaming.
  • Crab cakes: ½ tsp in the mix for 450 g crab meat.
  • Fries & corn: Dust straight after cooking.
Steamed blue crabs and shrimp dusted with Chesapeake-style seasoning, lemon and a crab mallet, finished with homemade chesapeake-style (old bay copycat) seasoning
Illustration

Substitutions and variations

  • No celery salt: 1½ tsp celery seed ground + 4½ tsp salt.
  • No ground bay: grind 3 dried bay leaves in a spice grinder.
  • Milder: skip the cayenne.

More questions about chesapeake-style

Is Old Bay spicy?

It is mild to medium: there is red and black pepper, but celery salt and paprika dominate. Our copycat is about 2/5.

Is Old Bay a Cajun seasoning?

No. Old Bay is a Chesapeake Bay (Maryland) seasoning built on celery salt and warm spices; Cajun seasoning is a Louisiana paprika-and-cayenne blend.

Chesapeake-style seasoning for crab cakes, shrimp boil and crab legs

Crab cakes: ½ tsp per 450 g crab meat. Shrimp boil: 3 tbsp per gallon of water. Crab legs: dust the shells after steaming and serve with melted butter.

Old Bay-style seasoning without celery salt

Grind 1½ tsp celery seed and mix with 4 tsp fine salt; the flavour is very close. If you cannot have celery, use extra mustard and paprika — it will be a different but still tasty seafood seasoning.

Where to buy Old Bay in the UK, Canada and Australia

The branded product can be hard to find outside the US, which is why many cooks in the UK, Canada and Australia make a homemade Chesapeake-style version like this one.

Photo guide

  • Steamed blue crabs and shrimp dusted with Chesapeake-style seasoning, lemon and a crab mallet, finished with homemade chesapeake-style (old bay copycat) seasoning

    Illustration

Recipes and guides to try it with

Chesapeake-Style FAQs

What is in Old Bay seasoning?+

The brand lists celery salt, spices (including red and black pepper) and paprika; copycats use celery salt, paprika, mustard, bay and warm spices.

Is this the real Old Bay?+

No. Old Bay® is a trademark of McCormick; this is our homemade Chesapeake-style version.

What can I substitute for Old Bay?+

This copycat, or celery salt + paprika + a pinch of cayenne. See our Old Bay substitute guide.

Is Old Bay spicy?+

Mild to medium; it is more savoury than hot.

Is Old Bay the same as Cajun seasoning?+

No. Old Bay is celery-salt based; Cajun is paprika and cayenne based.

How long does this copycat keep?+

6 months airtight.

Is this copycat gluten free?+

Yes, it is made only from spices and salt.

Is Old Bay good on chicken?+

Yes; Chesapeake-style seasoning is popular on wings, chicken and fries.