Lobster Roll

New England · United States

Lobster Roll

A lobster roll is about cold or barely warm lobster in a toasted split-top bun, not a hot boiled lobster at the table. Maine-style uses a light mayonnaise dressing. A warm butter roll (sometimes called Connecticut-style) tosses the meat in

Prep

20 min

Cook

10 min

Servings

4

Difficulty

Easy

By FishRestaurants.com Editorial. Method and timings were checked against our home-kitchen tests for this recipe. Editorial policy

  1. 1. Follow 7 steps
  2. 2. Check the ingredient list
  3. 3. Get the spice kit if you need our seasonings

A lobster roll is about cold or barely warm lobster in a toasted split-top bun, not a hot boiled lobster at the table. Maine-style uses a light mayonnaise dressing. A warm butter roll (sometimes called Connecticut-style) tosses the meat in melted butter instead.

Start with already cooked, cooled lobster. The how-to-cook lobster page covers boiling and steaming the meat.

Method

Work in order — each step builds on the last.

  1. Tossing cooked lobster for a roll01

    Dress the lobster, Maine-style

    If the meat is in large chunks, leave it that way. Toss it with the mayonnaise, optional celery, lemon juice and chives. Taste for salt. Keep it cold.

  2. Or warm it in butter — lobster recipe step02

    Or warm it in butter

    For a warm roll, skip the mayonnaise. Melt 3 tbsp butter, toss the lobster just to heat it through, and keep it warm.

  3. Toasting split-top buns in butter03

    Toast the buns

    Butter the outside faces of split-top buns and toast them in a skillet until golden.

  4. Fill — lobster recipe step04

    Fill

    Line the bun with a little lettuce if you like, and pile in the lobster generously.

  5. Lobster rolls in toasted buns05

    Serve at once

    A cold roll should still be cold; a warm roll should still be warm. Lemon on the side.

  6. Do not overdress — lobster recipe step06

    Do not overdress

    The bun and the lobster should be what you taste, not a heavy salad dressing.

  7. If you are cooking the lobster the same day — lobster recipe step07

    If you are cooking the lobster the same day

    Boil or steam it, chill it in an ice bath, then pick the meat. Warm meat in a mayonnaise roll will wilt the bun.

Chef's Match

Chef's Match: World Seafood Spice Pack

Ten coastal blends from shop.fishrestaurants.com — pairs with recipes and guides on this site.

Our shop →

For this recipe

Sea salt for this recipe

The one seasoning this recipe needs.

World Seafood Spice Pack · ten coastal blends, including Portuguese piri-piri and Greek lemon-oregano.

  • Sea salt

Same jars on every recipe that calls for them.

Shop the spices

Ingredients

Full shopping list for this recipe. Missing Sea salt? The spice kit has every seasoning listed here.

  • Cooked lobster meat, cooled, in large pieces1 lb
  • Mayonnaise3 tbsp, or less
  • Celery, finely diced, optional1/4 cup
  • Lemon juice1 tsp, plus wedges to serve
  • Chives or a pinch of celery saltto taste
  • Split-top hot dog buns4
  • Unsalted butter, softened, for the buns, plus 3 tbsp melted if making the warm version3 tbsp plus more for the warm roll
  • Lettuce, optional4 leaves

Chef tips

  • Split-top buns toast on the sides and hold the filling better than a standard bun.
  • Keep the pieces of claw and tail large enough to recognise.
  • A roll is best eaten immediately after assembly.

FAQ

Maine or warm butter?+

Maine-style is chilled lobster with a little mayonnaise. The warm version uses melted butter and no mayonnaise.

How much lobster per roll?+

About 4 oz of meat is a generous roll.

Can I use frozen lobster meat?+

Yes, if it is good quality. Thaw it in the fridge and drain it well.

What should I serve with it?+

Potato chips, a slaw, or a simple salad.

Keep exploring

Cook this recipe at home, then explore more recipes, stories, and places on FishRestaurants.com.

All recipes →All blog posts →

Affiliate links · Seafood

Affiliate · Some links are sponsored; we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.