East Coast oysters
Start with 6–12 from named farms — staff should know salinity.
Best seafood restaurants in New York
1,022 restaurants in New York
Start here
Three places to start in New York
Three rooms we would send a first-time visitor to — complete profiles, strong ratings, and a clear seafood focus.
More places worth knowing
Worth knowing in New York
A short second list for when the first three are booked, too far, or not the mood.
Premium partner
Blue Island Seafood On Wheels
Editor's pick
Boucherie West Village
4.8★ · 10,225
Editor's pick
La Grande Boucherie
4.6★ · 10,939
Editor's pick
Sozai Japanese Restaurant (Izakaya Ramen)
4.9★ · 4,567
Editor's pick
Uka Omakase
4.9★ · 4,382
Editor's pick
Fish Cheeks
4.7★ · 5,496
Editor's pick
Johnny's Reef
4.4★ · 9,564
Editor's pick
Sammy's Fish Box
4.3★ · 10,935
Top-rated picks
Top-rated picks in New York
Highly rated seafood restaurants in New York, chosen on ratings, reviews and complete profiles.
Dining tipsNew York oyster bars and fish housesThe best fish restaurants in New York are still raw bars that name the oyster farm and fish houses that print the lobster size. Lower East Side and the West Village stay intimate. Midtown is the high-volume room. Brooklyn adds market counters. Start here before you book a skyline table that never says where the fish came from.Read the full guide
The best fish restaurants in New York are still raw bars that name the oyster farm and fish houses that print the lobster size. Lower East Side and the West Village stay intimate. Midtown is the high-volume room. Brooklyn adds market counters. Start here before you book a skyline table that never says where the fish came from.
Planning seafood in New York? 1022 rated fish restaurants in one shortlist.
New York’s seafood scene runs from classic oyster bars and East Coast raw counters to modern fish houses in Manhattan and Brooklyn — order by neighbourhood and season, not only by skyline views.
Lower East Side and West Village favour intimate raw bars; Midtown and the Financial District skew toward high-volume institutions; Brooklyn adds market-linked and chef-driven fish rooms.
Searchers looking for “best seafood restaurants in New York” or “oysters NYC” should shortlist venues with a seafood-led menu, named East Coast oysters, and transparent market pricing on lobster.
What to order
East Coast raw bars
Oysters named by farm, lobster rolls, and whole branzino — NYC raw bars set the pace for American seafood dining.
Lobster roll
Connecticut butter vs Maine mayo — pick your camp.
Littleneck clams
Raw or steamed — classic raw-bar opener.
Whole grilled fish
Branzino or market catch — simple and revealing.
Local species & catches
Bluepoint oystersLobsterClamsFlukeStriped bass
Dining tips
- Order first
- East Coast oysters, littleneck clams, lobster roll (butter or mayo style), and simply cooked whole fish.
- Best areas
- Lower East Side and West Village for raw bars; Midtown for institutions; Brooklyn for chef-driven fish rooms.
- Skip
- Times Square seafood buffets and menus that never name the oyster farm or fish species.
Where to eat seafood in New York
West Village
4 placesClassic NYC fish houses and neighbourhood raw counters.
Midtown
6 placesHigh-volume institutions and business-lunch seafood.
Financial District
2 placesPower-lunch oysters and harbour-view rooms.
Brooklyn
223 placesMarket-linked fish rooms and chef-driven seafood.
Map of seafood restaurants in New York
Explore listed fish restaurants across New York, United States.
Browse by seafood style
All seafood categories →Seafood guides for New York
- Best seafood restaurants in the USA
Coast-to-coast picks across New York, Boston, Miami, San Francisco, and more.
- Best seafood restaurants in New York 2026
Rated NYC fish restaurants, oyster bars, and what to order by neighbourhood.
- New York seafood dining guide
Raw bars, coastal kitchens, and how to shortlist fish restaurants in NYC.
Nearby cities in United States
FAQ — New York
What should I order for seafood in New York?+
Start with East Coast oysters and a simply cooked fish or lobster. Prefer raw bars and fish houses that name the oyster farm and fish species.
Manhattan or Brooklyn for seafood?+
Manhattan concentrates classic oyster bars and Midtown institutions; Brooklyn adds market-linked and chef-driven rooms. Shortlist by rating on this directory.
What are the best seafood restaurants in New York?+
New York currently lists 1022 seafood and fish restaurants on FishRestaurants.com, sorted by rating and review volume where available.
Where can I find fish restaurants near me in New York?+
Use the map section and restaurant list on this page to compare locations across New York, then open individual profiles for address and hours.
What are the best grilled fish restaurants in New York?+
See the grilled fish category block for venues tagged with grilled fish and classic seafood grill styles.