Seafood delivery box — US fish delivery guide
By FishRestaurants.com Editorial. Buying advice is reviewed against seller labels and US food-safety guidance. Editorial policy · Updated 2026-11-07
Fish Delivery in the US: How to Order Great Seafood Online
**Disclosure:** Fishrestaurants.com may earn a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. Sizzlefish ships within the US only.
Most Americans live hours from the coast, and many grocery stores have a small fish counter or none at all. Ordering seafood online has become one of the easiest ways to cook good fish at home. This guide covers how delivery works, what to order first, and how to store and cook it, with links to our in-depth guides for each fish.
We don't rank delivery companies here. Instead, we explain what separates a good order from a disappointing one, so you can judge any seller yourself.
How frozen seafood delivery works
Nearly all online fish sellers ship frozen, not fresh. That's a good thing. Fish that's frozen quickly after it's caught or processed keeps its texture and flavor, and it gives you weeks or months to use it instead of a day or two.
A typical order works like this:
- You choose individual items or a mixed box. Many sellers also offer recurring deliveries.
- The fish is packed frozen in an insulated box with dry ice or gel packs.
- It ships by ground or express to arrive within a short window, usually on weekdays.
- You put it in the freezer as soon as it arrives.
What to check before you order
- Species and origin. US retail seafood must be labeled with its country of origin and as wild or farmed. Good sellers go further and name the fishery or region.
- Individual vacuum-sealed portions. These prevent freezer burn and let you thaw one meal at a time.
- Shipping area and delivery days. Some sellers ship to all 48 contiguous states, while others don't serve every state. Check before you build a cart.
- Customer service. Look for a clear policy on what happens if a box arrives thawed.
What to order first
If you're new to seafood delivery, start with versatile fish that suit lots of recipes.
Salmon
Salmon is the most popular fish in the US for a reason: it's rich, healthy and hard to get wrong. Choose wild sockeye or coho for a leaner, bolder fillet, king for a buttery one, or farmed Atlantic for a mild, forgiving option. Read the salmon guide and our wild salmon buying guide.
Rainbow trout
Trout is mild and thin, so it cooks in minutes. It's ideal for weeknights and for people who find salmon too strong. See the trout guide.
Cod
Cod is a lean, flaky white fish, perfect for fish and chips, fish tacos or baking with butter and lemon. See the cod guide.
Shrimp
Shrimp is the most-eaten seafood in the US. Frozen shrimp is the norm even at fish counters, where "fresh" shrimp has usually been previously frozen and thawed. Look for wild-caught US shrimp if origin matters to you. See the shrimp guide.
Scallops
Look for "dry" scallops, which have not been treated with phosphates. They sear to a deep golden crust instead of steaming in their own liquid. See the scallops guide.
For special occasions
- **Halibut:** thick, mild, meaty white fish, great pan-roasted.
- **Black cod (sablefish):** silky and rich, the fish behind the famous miso black cod.
- **Lobster:** frozen tails are easy to broil at home.
Storing frozen fish
- Keep your freezer at 0°F (-18°C) or below.
- Leave the fish in its original vacuum packaging until you use it.
- Use older items first. Write the delivery date on the box if needed.
- Frozen fish stays safe at 0°F indefinitely, but quality is best within a few months, so follow the seller's best-by date.
Thawing fish safely
- Fridge thaw (best): overnight in the refrigerator. Open or remove the vacuum packaging first, as most sellers instruct. Reduced-oxygen packaging shouldn't sit sealed in the fridge while thawing.
- Cold-water thaw (faster): submerge the sealed portion in cold water for 30–60 minutes, then cook right away.
- Cook from frozen: many thin fillets and shrimp can go straight into the oven or pan. Add a few minutes to the cooking time.
- Never thaw on the counter or in hot water.
Before cooking, pat fish completely dry. This gives you a better sear and crispier skin.
Cooking tips that work for most fish
- Heat the pan first. A hot pan and a thin layer of oil prevent sticking.
- Don't move it. Let fish form a crust before you flip it.
- Pull it early. Fish keeps cooking off the heat. The FDA recommends 145°F (63°C) internal temperature, or flesh that's opaque and flakes easily.
- Finish with acid. A squeeze of lemon or a spoon of salsa verde lifts almost any fish.
Find step-by-step ideas in our recipes:
.
Single orders vs mixed boxes vs subscriptions
- Single items suit you if you already know what you like.
- Mixed boxes let you try several species at once, which is a good way to discover new favorites.
- Subscriptions deliver on a schedule, so you always have fish in the freezer. Read our salmon subscription boxes guide to see whether one suits you.
About Sizzlefish
Sizzlefish is a US online seafood seller that ships frozen, individually packed portions. Its product pages describe:
- Wild Alaska salmon, including king, sockeye and coho, plus farm-raised Faroe Islands Atlantic salmon
- Rainbow trout farm-raised in the Colombian Andes
- Wild Atlantic cod and wild haddock from Iceland
- Wild Gulf and Carolina shrimp
- Wild Atlantic sea scallops
- Halibut, sablefish, lobster and crab
- Mixed boxes and subscription options
Sizzlefish ships within the US only.
Related guides
FAQ
Is frozen fish lower quality than fresh?
Not necessarily. Fish frozen quickly after it's caught often beats "fresh" fish that has spent days in transit. Much of the fish sold as fresh at counters has actually been previously frozen.
Will my fish arrive frozen?
Reputable sellers ship in insulated boxes with dry ice or gel packs, so the fish arrives frozen or very cold. Put it in the freezer right away and contact the seller if it arrives warm.
What fish should I order first?
Start with versatile options: salmon, rainbow trout, cod and shrimp. They suit lots of recipes and cooking methods.
Can I cook fish straight from frozen?
Yes, for thin fillets and shrimp. Rinse off any ice, pat them dry, and add a few minutes of cooking time. Thicker cuts cook more evenly if you thaw them first.
Do online fish sellers deliver everywhere in the US?
Not always. Shipping areas vary by seller, so check coverage for your ZIP code before you order. Sizzlefish ships within the US only.
Fishrestaurants.com may earn a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. Sizzlefish ships within the US only.
FAQ — Best Fish Delivery in the US: What to Look For
Is frozen fish lower quality than fresh?+
Not necessarily. Fish frozen quickly after it's caught often beats "fresh" fish that has spent days in transit. Much of the fish sold as fresh at counters has actually been previously frozen.
Will my fish arrive frozen?+
Reputable sellers ship in insulated boxes with dry ice or gel packs, so the fish arrives frozen or very cold. Put it in the freezer right away and contact the seller if it arrives warm.
What fish should I order first?+
Start with versatile options: salmon, rainbow trout, cod and shrimp. They suit lots of recipes and cooking methods.
Can I cook fish straight from frozen?+
Yes, for thin fillets and shrimp. Rinse off any ice, pat them dry, and add a few minutes of cooking time. Thicker cuts cook more evenly if you thaw them first.
Do online fish sellers deliver everywhere in the US?+
Not always. Shipping areas vary by seller, so check coverage for your ZIP code before you order. Sizzlefish ships within the US only. > Fishrestaurants.com may earn a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. Sizzlefish ships within the US only.