Best Old Bay Seasoning Substitutes

Quick answer

The best Old Bay substitute is a homemade mix of 2 tsp celery salt, 1 tsp paprika and ¼ tsp each black pepper and cayenne, used 1:1. Cajun seasoning plus a pinch of celery salt, or our copycat Chesapeake-style blend, also work well.

Four small bowls of homemade Old Bay substitutes on a wooden board: Chesapeake-style blend, Cajun seasoning, lemon pepper and celery salt, beside a plate of steamed shrimp

Side-by-side comparison

SubstituteRatio vs Old BayClosest forNotes
Copycat Chesapeake blend1:1EverythingClosest match; see recipe
Celery salt + paprika + pepper1:1Shrimp, crab, fries2-minute pantry fix
Cajun seasoning + celery salt1:1 + ¼ tsp celery saltBoils, shrimpHotter
Seafood seasoning1:1Fish, crab cakesMilder, more lemon
Seafood boil seasoning¾:1BoilsSaltier
Lemon pepper + celery salt1:1Fish, chickenBright, no warm spice

Old Bay substitute for a seafood boil

Use our seafood boil seasoning at ¾ the amount, or Cajun seasoning plus a pinch of celery salt and ground bay.

Old Bay substitute for crab cakes

Use ½ tsp of our Chesapeake-style blend per 450 g crab, or ¼ tsp celery salt plus ¼ tsp paprika and a pinch of mustard.

Old Bay substitute without celery salt

Mix 1 tsp ground celery seed with 2 tsp salt, 1 tsp paprika and a pinch of cayenne. If you cannot have celery, use our seafood seasoning without the celery salt.

Old Bay alternative in the UK, Canada and Australia

If you cannot find it locally, a homemade copycat is usually cheaper and fresher than imported tins.

Recipes and blends

FAQs

What is the closest substitute for Old Bay?+

A copycat blend of celery salt, paprika, mustard, bay and warm spices.

Can I use Cajun seasoning instead of Old Bay?+

Yes, with a pinch of celery salt; it will be hotter.

Is celery salt the main flavour in Old Bay?+

Yes, celery salt is listed first.

Can I use paprika instead of Old Bay?+

Paprika alone lacks the salt and celery; mix it with celery salt.

Is Old Bay the same as seafood seasoning?+

Old Bay® is a branded seafood seasoning by McCormick.

Can I use Old Bay instead of Cajun seasoning?+

Yes, but it is milder and saltier; add cayenne and paprika.