Cajun vs Creole Seasoning: What's the Difference?

Quick answer

Cajun seasoning is pepper-forward and hotter (paprika, cayenne, black and white pepper, garlic, onion), while Creole seasoning is herb-forward and milder, adding oregano, basil and thyme. You can swap them 1:1; add ½ tsp dried herbs per tbsp of Cajun to get closer to Creole.

Two bowls side by side on a wooden board: coarse brick-red Cajun seasoning on the left and herb-flecked deep red Creole seasoning on the right, with dried chillies and thyme between

Side-by-side comparison

CajunCreole
OriginRural Acadian LouisianaNew Orleans city cooking
Main flavourPeppery, smoky, hotHerby, savoury, rounder
Heat (1–5)32
Key spicesPaprika, cayenne, black & white pepperPaprika, oregano, basil, thyme, a little cayenne
Best forBoils, blackened fish, shrimp skilletsShrimp creole, gumbo, étouffée
Swap ratio1:1, add ½ tsp herbs1:1, add ¼ tsp cayenne

Cajun vs Creole seasoning for gumbo and jambalaya

Either works. Creole seasoning suits tomato-based (Creole) jambalaya and gumbo; Cajun seasoning suits brown, tomato-free Cajun jambalaya.

Cajun vs Creole vs Old Bay

Old Bay-style seasoning is a third style altogether: celery-salt based, from the Chesapeake Bay, milder than both.

Cajun vs Creole cooking

Creole cooking is the city cuisine of New Orleans with European, African and Caribbean roots, often using tomatoes and butter; Cajun cooking is rustic country food from Acadian settlers.

Recipes and blends

FAQs

Which is spicier, Cajun or Creole?+

Cajun is usually spicier.

Can I use Creole seasoning instead of Cajun?+

Yes, 1:1; add a pinch of cayenne.

Is Tony Chachere's Cajun or Creole?+

It is sold as Creole seasoning but tastes close to a salty Cajun blend.

Is Old Bay Cajun or Creole?+

Neither; it is a celery-salt Chesapeake blend.

Which is better for shrimp?+

Cajun for skillets and boils, Creole for saucy dishes like shrimp creole.

Is Cajun or Creole better for jambalaya?+

Creole for red (tomato) jambalaya, Cajun for brown jambalaya.